For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
Wuudy
I don't think he has much added value to Bitch as Keith please the lead on that song.
Can't you hear me Knocking and Gimme Shelter would be great.
I'll probably be a minority hear but I didn't like the Midnight Rambler versions that much... It was great to hear him play again but it was nowhere near the old versions. I prefer just Ronnie and Keith if Taylor plays the way he did in December.
I attended Brooklyn and thought the MR without Taylor was the best song on the night. While players like Eric Clapton and Jeff Beck have seemed to keep on top of their game Taylor has not stood the test of time as a solo artist or his 80's stints with The Bluesbreakers. In his day he was one of the most influential guitarists but 30 + years of playing with pick-up bands has not aged his playing well. Still he is the best choice for the 50+ tour as Keith and Ronnie could use some juice and the majority of us have been waiting for this moment. I predict he will dish out some great solos but things will get messy at times.. Really what are we paying to see? A couple of brilliant moments that hark us back to the golden era, a few belly laughs when things mess up and a giant celebration of the greatest band ever doing their utmost to stop time.Quote
VT22Quote
Wuudy
I don't think he has much added value to Bitch as Keith please the lead on that song.
Can't you hear me Knocking and Gimme Shelter would be great.
I'll probably be a minority hear but I didn't like the Midnight Rambler versions that much... It was great to hear him play again but it was nowhere near the old versions. I prefer just Ronnie and Keith if Taylor plays the way he did in December.
A very delicate statement. I didn't attend the concerts, but from what Ive heard on the internet, no one really took the the intiative from a musical point of view. It sounded like it could fall apart any moment.
Quote
Captainchaos
my god to hear this solo welded to the Stones would make me need to change my pants everytime!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
please make it so
Sorry, what I mean to say is if The Beatles toured this summer hypothetically, I'd be very happy if they just played the tunes from the red and blue greatest hits collections. If they muddled through quite a few I'd still think it a great show and go again and again. Same goes with The Stones, it's a marvelous miracle and they are doing it with a minimum of side people. I expect us all to have a grand time including them, somewhere down at the bottom of my list is music criticism or comparisons to their best moments. When the RS rehearsed for the first Hyde Park in the basement of Apple, John heard it as an awful mess, live they were an acquired taste then as well as now.Quote
Captainchaos
judas
Quote
mickschix
Mick J will have to keep Keith under control so that Mick T can shine without Keith's jealousy getting out of control and ruining the potential for some pure magic!