On the Get Yer Ya-Ya's Out LP, during the song Midnight Rambler, how many times does the "Goddamn" Man yell out?

I thought only once but someone else is saying twice.

If twice, at what times during the song?

Thanks.

How about the chick who says "Paint It Black...paint it Black You Devil" before Sympathy. Do you think the God Damn guy and her were actually both Live people from the audience or dubbed in afterwards for effect???

if I remember well, I read somewhere on the web an inteview of the lady shot the "Paint it Black ..."

Theres something on youtube about the woman who claims to be the one yelling out "PIB" but she was yelling that before the show started...guess they just thought it sounded nice spliced in right before
Sympathy"...

The PIB plea is also dubbed onto Atlantic City '89...so probably doing the rounds!

Edith Grove posted an interview of the PIB Woman. She claims the GYYYO LP got its title from her. The PIB Woman, not Edith.

I've always thought he was yelling, "Hot damn."

The "Paint It Black, you devil" girl is overdubbed onto Flashpoint, too.

Quote
MILKYWAY
On the Get Yer Ya-Ya's Out LP, during the song Midnight Rambler, how many times does the "Goddamn" Man yell out?

I thought only once but someone else is saying twice.

If twice, at what times during the song?

Thanks.

I thought talking about religion was not allowed on IORR ..............

__________________________

Quote
pjs425
The PIB plea is also dubbed onto Atlantic City '89...so probably doing the rounds!

Flashpoint, no?

Quote
scottkeef
Theres something on youtube about the woman who claims to be the one yelling out "PIB" but she was yelling that before the show started...guess they just thought it sounded nice spliced in right before
Sympathy"...

That's one of the reasons bootlegs are useful. She screamed before the show. Oh, and Altamont wasn'st like the movie suggests. The bootlegs don't lie to me (and you).

I thought she said "Paint it black, you Devil"

I saw the documentary Crumb about the cartoonist R. Crumb, after which the director talked to the audience. One scene shows Crumb's brother saying something cruel, and then the camera cuts to Crumb laughing uproariously, and you think how vicious. But the director admitted the two moments were completely separate and he'd edited them together. I could tell the audience thought, "That's taking poetic license too far."

Oh, incidentally, the Stones wanted R. Crumb to draw an album cover, and he turned them down.



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2014-05-01 23:05 by Title5Take1.

Maybe the woman who yelled "PIB you Devil" attended many shows....

...I have a friend who's seen Eric Burdon dozens of times and each time he yells out "Gemini the Mad Man"!...

it was good humour to put the "Paint it Black girl" on Flashpoint and finally give her what she yelled for.

Is she related to the Guy who yells "Paint It Black!" before Let it Rock?

Quote
steini
it was good humour to put the "Paint it Black girl" on Flashpoint and finally give her what she yelled for.

Whats funny is I believe its not even put in before they play Paint It Black. I thought it was like before they play like Ruby Tuesday or something.

Quote
tklawson
Is she related to the Guy who yells "Paint It Black!" before Let it Rock?

The guy on Let It Rock does not yell Paint Y Black...
He yells Let It Rock!
Listen again...

Quote
DandelionPowderman

Quote
pjs425
The PIB plea is also dubbed onto Atlantic City '89...so probably doing the rounds!

Flashpoint, no?

yes its on Flashpoint also. Before You Can't Always Get What You Want

What always gets me is that screech in the break right after the "God Damn" break. It's in the stops of "Rambler". They go "Well you heard about the Boston" Bam! and then it's the 'God Damn' guy; then "Honey it's not one of those", and that is where that unearthly shriek comes in, LOL

Quote
kleermaker

Quote
scottkeef
Theres something on youtube about the woman who claims to be the one yelling out "PIB" but she was yelling that before the show started...guess they just thought it sounded nice spliced in right before
Sympathy"...

That's one of the reasons bootlegs are useful. She screamed before the show. Oh, and Altamont wasn'st like the movie suggests. The bootlegs don't lie to me (and you).

Why would someone yell out a song request before the concert, when no one was onstage?

Quote
tatters

Quote
kleermaker

Quote
scottkeef
Theres something on youtube about the woman who claims to be the one yelling out "PIB" but she was yelling that before the show started...guess they just thought it sounded nice spliced in right before
Sympathy"...

That's one of the reasons bootlegs are useful. She screamed before the show. Oh, and Altamont wasn'st like the movie suggests. The bootlegs don't lie to me (and you).

Why would someone yell out a song request before the concert, when no one was onstage?

Because it was the 60"s ?

Fans who are fans of other fans.

The "Goddamn Man" ought to put out a retrospective compilation CD, complete with all the goddamn outtakes.

Quote
Blueranger

Quote
tklawson
Is she related to the Guy who yells "Paint It Black!" before Let it Rock?

The guy on Let It Rock does not yell Paint Y Black...
He yells Let It Rock!
Listen again...

There was a thread abut this. How did the that yelled "Let it Rock" kknow that they were going to play that song...unless it was someone from the stage...if that's what he said (which it sounds like). They only played it once on that tour, am I correct?

So much of Ya Ya's was overdubbed. All my childhood I believed this was how good the Stones actually were. Than I woke up and realized they'd never sounded that good in their lives and I had to learn to deal with that. Overdubbing most of their best ever live album really disappointed me and I never looked at them the same way again. Even the Rolling Stones were fake. I grew up the day I learned that and I still wish that day had never come.

Quote
Title5Take1
Oh, incidentally, the Stones wanted R. Crumb to draw an album cover, and he turned them down.

Any more info about that? Why did he turn it down?

Quote
blivet

Quote
Title5Take1
Oh, incidentally, the Stones wanted R. Crumb to draw an album cover, and he turned them down.

Any more info about that? Why did he turn it down?

He doesn't like their music. Or any modern music.

“I thought their band was lame. I’m stuck on old music, from the 1920s and 30s — most of the covers have been for that kind of music, whether with contemporary people playing it or reissues of old records. I don’t care much for modern rock’n'roll. I did a cover for Janis Joplin, but she came personally and asked me. And I needed the money.”
--Robert Crumb

Quote
rob51
So much of Ya Ya's was overdubbed. All my childhood I believed this was how good the Stones actually were. Than I woke up and realized they'd never sounded that good in their lives and I had to learn to deal with that. Overdubbing most of their best ever live album really disappointed me and I never looked at them the same way again. Even the Rolling Stones were fake. I grew up the day I learned that and I still wish that day had never come.

Wow, the BS is flying hot and heavy here today, folks. As has been discussed in great depth here many, many times, the amount of overdubbing on GYYYO is extremely minimal. 6 tunes have overdubbing of the vocals, only one of which is substantial-JJFlash. This was due to MJ deciding that it should sound like the phrasing of the single rather than the way he sang it on the entire 69 tour.
The "But it's alright, yeah it's alright" as opposed to the familiar "But it's alllllright now" phrasing.

There are a couple of other small things, but all are done for technical issues; none to cover for any lack of excellence or to give a different impression of what actually took place. The audience tapes bear this out. The Rolling Stones actually were that un-freaking believable. Legend? YES; Myth? NO

I understand your irritation, but it has been researched to a microscopic level, and the fraud that you sense happened? It just ain't so. For all the smoking guns and spent shells forensic breakdown check out ChrisM's exhaustive work at-
[www.rollingstonesnet.com]
and have your beautiful childhood visions returned to you.

Quote
rob51
So much of Ya Ya's was overdubbed. All my childhood I believed this was how good the Stones actually were. Than I woke up and realized they'd never sounded that good in their lives and I had to learn to deal with that. Overdubbing most of their best ever live album really disappointed me and I never looked at them the same way again. Even the Rolling Stones were fake. I grew up the day I learned that and I still wish that day had never come.

Only some vocals and two rhythm guitar tracks. The Stones WERE that good.

Why did you believe that more was overdubbed?

Quote
DandelionPowderman

Quote
rob51
So much of Ya Ya's was overdubbed. All my childhood I believed this was how good the Stones actually were. Than I woke up and realized they'd never sounded that good in their lives and I had to learn to deal with that. Overdubbing most of their best ever live album really disappointed me and I never looked at them the same way again. Even the Rolling Stones were fake. I grew up the day I learned that and I still wish that day had never come.

Only some vocals and two rhythm guitar tracks. The Stones WERE that good.

Why did you believe that more was overdubbed?

And those overdubs didn't even improve the music at all. So the Stones were even better.