For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
rob51
Don't know for certain but I'd bet that that entire story about losing her baby is bs.
Quote
mickschix
I really doubt that 3 takes of Gimme Shelter, no matter how powerful it was, caused a miscarriage! Really, think about it...singing causing a baby in the womb to DIE!? Nope, I don't buy it. You'd have to suspect that the tale grew and grew with each re-telling!! The myth that was created just kept getting repeated. No one heard that she was very ill with the flu?
Quote
swissQuote
mickschix
I really doubt that 3 takes of Gimme Shelter, no matter how powerful it was, caused a miscarriage! Really, think about it...singing causing a baby in the womb to DIE!? Nope, I don't buy it. You'd have to suspect that the tale grew and grew with each re-telling!! The myth that was created just kept getting repeated. No one heard that she was very ill with the flu?
A miscarriage is a spontaneous abortion. Partcularly if someone is predisposed to miscarry,
and particularly if they are not far along, it is completely possible to miscarry from intense
emotional and/or physical strain.
- swiss
Quote
PietroQuote
swissQuote
mickschix
I really doubt that 3 takes of Gimme Shelter, no matter how powerful it was, caused a miscarriage! Really, think about it...singing causing a baby in the womb to DIE!? Nope, I don't buy it. You'd have to suspect that the tale grew and grew with each re-telling!! The myth that was created just kept getting repeated. No one heard that she was very ill with the flu?
A miscarriage is a spontaneous abortion. Partcularly if someone is predisposed to miscarry,
and particularly if they are not far along, it is completely possible to miscarry from intense
emotional and/or physical strain.
- swiss
Possible, yes. But that doesn't mean you can blame her singing on "Gimme Shelter" for her "spontaneous abortion."
"Spontaneous abortion"?
Quote
mickschix
I really doubt that 3 takes of Gimme Shelter, no matter how powerful it was, caused a miscarriage! Really, think about it...singing causing a baby in the womb to DIE!? Nope, I don't buy it. You'd have to suspect that the tale grew and grew with each re-telling!! The myth that was created just kept getting repeated. No one heard that she was very ill with the flu?
Quote
schillid
The power of that song is probably why they use Lisa Fischer nowadays...