For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
stonesrule
The decline of Keith Moon was horrible to watch.
Death was the most merciful thing that could happen to him.
Quote
whitem8Quote
stonesrule
The decline of Keith Moon was horrible to watch.
Death was the most merciful thing that could happen to him.
What a sad and ignorant thing to say.
Quote
stonesrule
I knew Keith Moon for the last ten years of his life. It was heartbreaking to see his decline.
Quote
whitem8Quote
stonesrule
I knew Keith Moon for the last ten years of his life. It was heartbreaking to see his decline.
I guess you weren't his friend or a family member. While he struggled with addiction and was in bad shape, he had a loving family, and friends who were devastated by his death. And they would much rather have had him live than die. It is respectful to honor someone's passing and cherish their memory.
And yes, Keefriffhard, he did struggle with drumming on Who Are You, but he also re-did his drum parts on Who Are You, and in the end his re-recorded drums sound pretty good.
Quote
GumbootCloggeroo
Keith with Paul and Linda McCartney. He died a few hours later.
Quote
stonesrule
whitem8, yes, I was a friend with great memories of a happy and wonderfully witty and amusing Keith Moon.
And it is extremely painful to watch another human being lose their joy.
I certainly was not the only one who felt this way in the last year of Keith's life. He was miserable and going down hill physically, mentally and emotionally.
He became a danger to himself and to others.
Sorry that my honesty is not what you were looking for.
Quote
keefriffhard4lifeQuote
whitem8Quote
stonesrule
The decline of Keith Moon was horrible to watch.
Death was the most merciful thing that could happen to him.
What a sad and ignorant thing to say.
it even mentions in the reissue of WHO ARE YOU how bad moons drumming had declined in less than 2 years. he was so bad by the time they started recording WHO ARE YOU that the band removed some drums from his set. his parts were also removed or never used for a few songs on that album because he never got the parts right
The song was The Music Must Change, and as was stated not his style. And I was referring the entire album Who are You, not the song. A lot of his drums had to be re-recorded. Rather be dead than play drums? Your missing the point. The point is showing respect for a man's life and death and to imagine he is better off dead is like fast forwarding on his behalf. Who knows what Keith could have done had he lived?Quote
keefriffhard4lifeQuote
whitem8Quote
stonesrule
I knew Keith Moon for the last ten years of his life. It was heartbreaking to see his decline.
I guess you weren't his friend or a family member. While he struggled with addiction and was in bad shape, he had a loving family, and friends who were devastated by his death. And they would much rather have had him live than die. It is respectful to honor someone's passing and cherish their memory.
And yes, Keefriffhard, he did struggle with drumming on Who Are You, but he also re-did his drum parts on Who Are You, and in the end his re-recorded drums sound pretty good.
i was talking about the album not the song. i can't recall what song it is but there was a tune in 6/8 time on the album that moon messed up his drum part so badly they just scrapped it and had him do just cymnal hits to accent the song.
anyways why do you assume keith would want to live if he could no longer play the drums and the who possibly would have axed him? seems like moon would rather be dead than alive but unable to do what he loved.
Quote
whitem8The song was The Music Must Change, and as was stated not his style. And I was referring the entire album Who are You, not the song. A lot of his drums had to be re-recorded. Rather be dead than play drums? Your missing the point. The point is showing respect for a mans life and death and to imagine he is better of dead is like fast forwarding on his behalf. Who knows what Keith could have done had he lived?Quote
keefriffhard4lifeQuote
whitem8Quote
stonesrule
I knew Keith Moon for the last ten years of his life. It was heartbreaking to see his decline.
I guess you weren't his friend or a family member. While he struggled with addiction and was in bad shape, he had a loving family, and friends who were devastated by his death. And they would much rather have had him live than die. It is respectful to honor someone's passing and cherish their memory.
And yes, Keefriffhard, he did struggle with drumming on Who Are You, but he also re-did his drum parts on Who Are You, and in the end his re-recorded drums sound pretty good.
i was talking about the album not the song. i can't recall what song it is but there was a tune in 6/8 time on the album that moon messed up his drum part so badly they just scrapped it and had him do just cymnal hits to accent the song.
anyways why do you assume keith would want to live if he could no longer play the drums and the who possibly would have axed him? seems like moon would rather be dead than alive but unable to do what he loved.
Well, it is pointless trying rationalize good taste and etiquette.
Quote
ValeswoodQuote
keefriffhard4lifeQuote
whitem8Quote
stonesrule
The decline of Keith Moon was horrible to watch.
Death was the most merciful thing that could happen to him.
What a sad and ignorant thing to say.
it even mentions in the reissue of WHO ARE YOU how bad moons drumming had declined in less than 2 years. he was so bad by the time they started recording WHO ARE YOU that the band removed some drums from his set. his parts were also removed or never used for a few songs on that album because he never got the parts right
The song you are referring to is Music Must Change and I think it was more that his style of drumming did not suit the track rather than his ability to play (or is that the same thing?). His drumming on the rest of the LP is great particularly the title track - watch the promo video as opposed to listeing to the album track.
RIP Keith, you are still the greatest