For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
24FPS
Brian got the same Darwinian logic applied to him that was applied to Stu, and attempted on Bill. Stu wasn't good looking enough, goodbye. Bill wasn't quite right, so, me, Brian, I'll just try and learn the bass and we'll be rid of 'Ernie'.
Flash forward to 1969, Brian can't perform up to snuff. Looks like hell. Can't get his shit together. Bye. Nevermind the personal animosities built up since 1962 between Brian and every member of the band, this was plain and simple. Brian Jones couldn't cut it anymore.
Quote
SweetThingQuote
24FPS
Brian got the same Darwinian logic applied to him that was applied to Stu, and attempted on Bill. Stu wasn't good looking enough, goodbye. Bill wasn't quite right, so, me, Brian, I'll just try and learn the bass and we'll be rid of 'Ernie'.
Flash forward to 1969, Brian can't perform up to snuff. Looks like hell. Can't get his shit together. Bye. Nevermind the personal animosities built up since 1962 between Brian and every member of the band, this was plain and simple. Brian Jones couldn't cut it anymore.
I believe this above is more or less uncontested in the final time with the Stones, however it is Bill Wyman who describes Brian Jones in good spirits and planning for the future musically after being fired.
While I can easily imagine this "optimism" on Brian's part being quite thin, and perhaps just manic behavior while in denial, or perhaps after a brief interlude from quite as many drugs, Wyman's recounting of Jones listening to Credence Clearwater Revival all day long is very interesting!!!!!!
For a guy that seemed to be becoming musically incompatible with the Stones, by some accounts drifting into avant-garde electronic music, I found myself wondering if he might not have, suddenly, become just as interested in doing a 180% turn musically (if he could pull it off in his health is another matter) as Mick and Keith. Surely Brian knew Jumping Jack Flash was a brilliant song, even if he had little to nothing to do with writing it.
What most people say is that Brian became another person after he was out of the band. He became happier, cut down his drinking and seem relieved that he was "free". Several people say he was very much into the idea of getting a new act together and there are musicians who claim that they met or talked with Brian during this time. Korner claim that Brian felt a huge weight had lifted from his shoulders after he was out of the Stones. He was working hard and was in good spirit. Brian's dad and the people in the household at Cotchford say the same thing.Quote
Redhotcarpet
Brian didnt make any pragmatic choices from 1967 other than take something to numb out life and now and then he made choices to try to find a place in the band. If you read between the lines you get the real picture imo. Korner and Watts both say he had nothing left when he was sacked. Brian himself said the same thing. Brians father says the obvious thing: once he lost Anita it was over more or less. Sure the busts made him real paranoid for good reasons but the real damage was Anita and the total loss of any kind of power in the band. Noone seems to really believe he would form any band after the Stones. Korner said Brian died at the "right time" when he still could try to believe there was a future. Korner didnt want to start a band with Brian because of the state he was in. The man cried when he was sacked. Suicide is no farfetched theory its the most obvious answer. Keith thought he drowned himself but yes, that Frank T. might have "done him in".
My conclusion when I read what people who were there said is that Brian had one thing left and that was being a Rolling Stone no matter how hard that was.
True. But the problem to bring Brian on tour was just an excuse. Even without that problem they would still have had to replace him as it just didn't work anymore.Quote
mickschix
Brian had become an albatross around the bands' neck with all of his drug convictions...they wouldn't be able to tour with Brian in the band! End of story...he had to be fred. Watching Goddards' film " One Plus One-Sympathy For The Devil" can be boring but it's also very telling...Brian slumped in a corner of the studio, unable to move, let alone play...He was a liability by then, useless to them.
But Beggars seem to be the last album before musical input from the other members was cut and I think that was also a reason why Brian got fed up. He didn't want to be the second guitarist. He wanted to express himself and experiment. But there was no room anymore.Quote
24FPS
It appears that no matter how 'Briancentric' the new music the Stones were making was, Brian could no longer handle the fact that he was a sideman to Mick and Keith's songs. Even if those new compositions were perfect for Brian's interests. Which makes Brian even more maddening. Here, Brian, we're playing blues, country rock, some rhythm and blues, like the old days, buddy. Just pick up that guitar and play. Something inside Brian prevented him from doing that, except for his sad farewell on No Expectations, proving, maddingly again, that he still had the magic, the talent, but he refused to share it with the band. Goodbye. We'll find someone less passive aggressive, and we'll conquer the world.
Give me the evidence. He is present on almost every song and went through hell with depression during that time. If he showed up they ignored him or asked Miller to tell him to @#$%& off and if he didn't show up he was unreliable.Quote
Bliss
>>Brian ceased to be productive in mid 68 when the shit hit the fan with the second bust.
As far as Brian being productive til mid 68, there is a lot of evidence that contradicts that. From early on, he was unreliable about turning up for recording sessions and even concerts, often due to his health issues (according to Keith). Additionally, by the time they did Aftermath, he had lost interest in the guitar, and wanted to play other instruments. He gave them a hard time about Satanic Majesties.
And on a personal level, he was directly responsible for the Redlands bust which had such devastating consequences for Mick, Keith, Marianne and Robert Fraser.
Ah yes. The "sampled LSD" incident. What an idiot.Quote
Bliss
From Wikipedia:
'A (News of the World) reporter who contributed to the story spent an evening at the exclusive London club Blaise’s, where a member of the Stones allegedly took several Benzedrine tablets, displayed a piece of hashish and invited his companions back to his flat for a “smoke”. The article claimed that this was Mick Jagger, but it turned out to be a case of mistaken identity—the reporter had in fact been eavesdropping on Brian Jones. On the night the article was published Jagger appeared on the Eamonn Andrews chat show and announced that he was filing a writ for libel against the paper.
A week later on Sunday 12 February, Sussex police, tipped off by the News of the World, who in turn were tipped off by Richards’ chauffeur, raided a party at Keith Richards’ home, Redlands. No arrests were made at the time but Jagger, Richards and their friend Robert Fraser (an art dealer) were subsequently charged with drugs offences. '
No, I don't. But I do know that the glimmers or mainly Keith takes every chance he gets nowadays to swing shit at Brian. If they share your thoughts then I'm pretty sure we would have heard something about it. At least they didn't seem to hold any grudge against him back then since Mick showed up at both of Brian's trials and Keith at the first.Quote
Bliss
Tonterapi, you have no idea what Mick, Keith, Marianne or Robert Fraser thought. Mick was angry enough at being falsely accused to publicly declare his intention to clear his name in court. Robert Fraser went to prison as a result of the raid.
Totally agree. Brian made a huge mistake. But I do believe that the busts would have happend anyway sooner or later since the moral conservative part of England didn't like the rock n roll bands. Norman Pilcher was a nightmare for both the fab four and the RS. I'm glad he got what he deserved.Quote
Bliss
But it is plain that Brian's indiscretion set off the chain of events which led to the Redlands bust. It's possible that anything else could have been a catalyst for a similar raid. The police were clearly at war with the RS and their illegal drug use was the means for the police to get to them. However, even if nothing were found, they were still vulnerable; it was not unknown for the police to plant evidence to achieve their ends.
Quote
tonterapi
What most people say is that Brian became another person after he was out of the band. He became happier, cut down his drinking and seem relieved that he was "free". Several people say he was very much into the idea of getting a new act together and there are musicians who claim that they met or talked with Brian during this time. Korner claim that Brian felt a huge weight had lifted from his shoulders after he was out of the Stones. He was working hard and was in good spirit. Brian's dad and the people in the household at Cotchford say the same thing.
I have never read anyone comment Brian's chances to form a new band. The question is if those who have comment that met Brian during this time at all?
This is interesting because it's the opposite of what I think really. Always refreshing to see other angles.Quote
Redhotcarpet
Think about it for a moment. He would never have formed that band and he would never have made it anywhere with any kind of band and he would never have achieved any kind of success near the monumental success story the Stones became.
Quote
mickschix
Brian had become an albatross around the bands' neck with all of his drug convictions...they wouldn't be able to tour with Brian in the band! End of story...he had to be fred. Watching Goddards' film " One Plus One-Sympathy For The Devil" can be boring but it's also very telling...Brian slumped in a corner of the studio, unable to move, let alone play...He was a liability by then, useless to them.
Quote
RedhotcarpetQuote
tonterapi
What most people say is that Brian became another person after he was out of the band. He became happier, cut down his drinking and seem relieved that he was "free". Several people say he was very much into the idea of getting a new act together and there are musicians who claim that they met or talked with Brian during this time. Korner claim that Brian felt a huge weight had lifted from his shoulders after he was out of the Stones. He was working hard and was in good spirit. Brian's dad and the people in the household at Cotchford say the same thing.
I have never read anyone comment Brian's chances to form a new band. The question is if those who have comment that met Brian during this time at all?
Yes exactly, free from having to make it to the studio, make excuses for not turning up, feel from having to feel hated for not turning up, feel from his past and image and devasting last three years and free from having to deal with a horrible reality. Whats next then. Forming a new band? Korner's point was that he was glad Brian died on an "up" when he might have dreamed of forming a new band. Korner implied that this was just a dream, a thought during those few weeks before he died. Brian Jones also told Janet (I think it was) that he felt he was in hell and wanted to be in heaven (or something like that). Reading the bible, crying then suddenly forming a band making plans, then doing drugs, then stopping, then drinking. And this is the three weeks after they fired him. Sounds like the typical main spiral a suicidal person often have.
There is just no way Brian Jones could have coped with reality once the Stones went touring, Anita had her baby, they released Let it bleed, toured the States again in 1972 got richer and richer and more and more powerful and famous etc. Think about it for a moment. He would never have formed that band and he would never have made it anywhere with any kind of band and he would never have achieved any kind of success near the monumental success story the Stones became.
Quote
mickschix
I'm not sure " ALL OF THOSE BUSTS" would have happened if Brian hadn't been so careless. ( well, Keith too for that matter. I'm not sure what you saw as productive in Brian during " One Plus One", the parts I recall clearly show a wastd Brian...so ok, not 100% of the time, but a lot of the time in the studio.
Quote
BlissQuote
RedhotcarpetQuote
tonterapi
What most people say is that Brian became another person after he was out of the band. He became happier, cut down his drinking and seem relieved that he was "free". Several people say he was very much into the idea of getting a new act together and there are musicians who claim that they met or talked with Brian during this time. Korner claim that Brian felt a huge weight had lifted from his shoulders after he was out of the Stones. He was working hard and was in good spirit. Brian's dad and the people in the household at Cotchford say the same thing.
I have never read anyone comment Brian's chances to form a new band. The question is if those who have comment that met Brian during this time at all?
Yes exactly, free from having to make it to the studio, make excuses for not turning up, feel from having to feel hated for not turning up, feel from his past and image and devasting last three years and free from having to deal with a horrible reality. Whats next then. Forming a new band? Korner's point was that he was glad Brian died on an "up" when he might have dreamed of forming a new band. Korner implied that this was just a dream, a thought during those few weeks before he died. Brian Jones also told Janet (I think it was) that he felt he was in hell and wanted to be in heaven (or something like that). Reading the bible, crying then suddenly forming a band making plans, then doing drugs, then stopping, then drinking. And this is the three weeks after they fired him. Sounds like the typical main spiral a suicidal person often have.
There is just no way Brian Jones could have coped with reality once the Stones went touring, Anita had her baby, they released Let it bleed, toured the States again in 1972 got richer and richer and more and more powerful and famous etc. Think about it for a moment. He would never have formed that band and he would never have made it anywhere with any kind of band and he would never have achieved any kind of success near the monumental success story the Stones became.
Well, not achieving RS-level success does not necessarily mean failure! Brian was a highly intelligent, articulate, creative and musically-gifted man before his life spiraled downward due to drinking, drugs, legal nightmares, and devastating betrayals. It's not impossible that he might have recovered his earlier passion and productivity, perhaps in the sphere of producing world music.
Quote
Redhotcarpet
That's how he was and that lifestyle and personality is what created the Stones and the Stones way of life.
I think that you're refering to the edited clip they included in the 25x5 documentary. While they talk about Brian's problems in 68 they show clips from Godards movie and added pictures of Brian from the We Love You promo where he clearly is out of his head on mandrax (or something like it).Quote
mickschix
I'm not sure " ALL OF THOSE BUSTS" would have happened if Brian hadn't been so careless. ( well, Keith too for that matter. I'm not sure what you saw as productive in Brian during " One Plus One", the parts I recall clearly show a wastd Brian...so ok, not 100% of the time, but a lot of the time in the studio.
Quote
Redhotcarpet
Well I like the Joujouka and the recording fits Brian and Stones perfectly. But there is a fine line as far as world music goes and I believe Brian was aware of that. The Joujouka is just a hazy recording, it's cool and a good thing but I doubt he had any real interest in world music. Besides theres another problem: money. His lifestyle, the house etc would not have lasted long outside the band. He was worried about money at the time of his death. (I know he was relieved about the settlement but that sounds like a short hasty promise of a pay-off that was never delivered)